ARTICLES, INSIGHTS & IDEAS
by Eli Mina
BACK TO "RULES OF ORDER" MENU
AVOIDING NASTY SURPRISES AT A MEETING
By Eli Mina, M.Sc.

The agenda has just about ended. Most members are tired and ready to go home. But then one member complicates matters by making a surprise motion. Everyone is frustrated and resents being ambushed. How might you prevent or deal with such a situation?

Surprise motions can be an unfair imposition on the group. They may lead to a solution being considered without knowing what the problem is. Last minute motions should be the exception, and not the norm. Your group should make a conscious decision not to tolerate green bananas (items that are not ripe for decision making). Members should understand the inherent risks of last minute proposals: They should appreciate that, without preparation and a deliberate and measured thought process – they may make bad decisions that they will live to regret.

Here are two ideas to help your group prevent or deal with such situations:

  • Preventively, establish the importance of having a gradual and measured decision-making process. You may even establish a written policy, stating that surprise proposals will be automatically postponed to a future meeting, unless the group, collectively, agrees that it is imperative to finalize a decision on such a proposal at that meeting.


  • At the meeting itself, the process would be as follows: When a last minute motion (a green banana) is introduced, the chair would remind the proponent of the rule that a new proposal may not be finalized at the same meeting. If the member persists and suggests that the item is urgent, the Chair would take a vote: "Those who think this motion should be dealt with today raise your hands. Thank you. Those who believe we should follow our normal procedure of having new motions postponed to a future meeting raise your hands. Thank you. The motion will be considered at the next meeting."


PREVIOUS ARTICLE     BACK TO "RULES OF ORDER" MENU     NEXT ARTICLE

BACK TO MAIN ARTICLES MENU
 


Information about Eli Mina:

Eli Mina, M.Sc., PRP, is a Vancouver (Canada) based management consultant, executive coach, and Registered Parliamentarian. In business since 1984, Eli consults his clients on board effectiveness, chairing contentious meetings, preventing and dealing with disputes and dysfunctions, demystifying the rules of order, and minute taking standards. Eli's clients come from municipal government, school boards, regulatory bodies, credit unions, colleges and universities, native communities, businesses, and the non-profit sector.

Eli is the author of the newly published "101 Boardroom Problems and How to Solve Them." He is also the author of several other books and publications on meetings, shared decision-making and minute taking (see Eli Mina's Books at www.elimina.com ). Eli can be reached at 604-730-0377 or via e-mail at eli@elimina.com.


TOP OF PAGE

 
Eli Mina Consulting | Email | 604-730-0377